分析: 亚伦·布莱克
2小时前
发布时间: 2026年2月17日,美国东部时间下午4:42
联邦机构 国家安全 恐怖主义 唐纳德·特朗普
国土安全部发言人特里西娅·麦克劳克林即将离职,这是特朗普政府激进驱逐策略重新调整的最新迹象。该策略已严重失去美国民众支持。而该部门过度激进、糟糕且常常怪异的信息发布,在其中扮演了关键角色,其影响之大难以言表。
政府与下周离职的麦克劳克林似乎认为,无论证据如何,他们都可以随意谈论诸如联邦移民局特工枪杀雷妮·古德和亚历克斯·普雷蒂等事件。但事实证明,这种做法带来了政治后果。
本月早些时候的一项昆尼皮亚克大学民调显示,登记选民以超过2:1的比例(61%-25%)表示,他们认为政府没有对1月底在明尼阿波利斯发生的普雷蒂枪击事件给出“诚实的说明”。
即使在共和党人中,也有40%的人不愿为政府担保。(约一半人持中立态度,另一半人表示不信任)。
这种声誉的受损并非仅仅来自政府对普雷蒂枪击事件的拙劣处理,还源于其对众多其他备受瞩目的事件的处理。近几个月来,国土安全部反复发布声明,却屡屡被视频、其他证据、当地警方和/或法官推翻。其针对被指控袭击联邦特工者提起的法律诉讼也多次失败。
普雷蒂被杀事件或许是该部门信息发布失误最令人震惊的例子,但此类事件屡见不鲜——包括在麦克劳克林离职消息公布前不久,我们了解到的更多类似案例。(美国有线电视新闻网报道称,她在12月就开始计划离职,但在明尼阿波利斯枪击事件后留任。)
以下是国土安全部一些重大声明被推翻的例子:
雷妮·古德(1月7日)
声明: 麦克劳克林称古德“将车辆用作武器,企图杀害或伤害联邦执法人员”。国土安全部部长克里斯蒂·诺姆称之为“国内恐怖主义行为”。总统唐纳德·特朗普称古德“故意恶意碾压”特工。
证据: 移民和海关执法局特工乔纳森·罗斯并未被碾压。车辆是否接触到他存在疑问,但没有证据表明古德意图碾压特工;事实上,古德驾车驶离时正背对特工,随后被开枪击中。视频证据显示,罗斯甚至在车辆侧面继续向她开枪。
亚历克斯·普雷蒂(1月24日)
声明: 麦克劳克林称普雷蒂似乎试图“屠杀执法人员”。诺姆再次援引“国内恐怖主义”。白宫顾问斯蒂芬·米勒称普雷蒂是“刺客”,“试图谋杀联邦特工”。
证据: 视频证据比古德案更强烈地反驳了这些说法。没有证据表明普雷蒂针对特工。他虽合法持有武器,但未拔枪,且在被枪杀前已被缴械。政府随后收回了这些指控。
马里马尔·马丁内斯(2025年10月4日)
声明: 古德和普雷蒂并非首个被指控恐怖主义的美国公民。边境巡逻队特工在芝加哥多次枪击马丁内斯后,国土安全部发表声明称,涉事特工“遭到国内恐怖分子伏击,其车辆被恐怖分子冲撞”。声明称枪击是“防御性”的。麦克劳克林补充道:“我们不会允许国内恐怖分子袭击我们的执法人员。”
证据: 上周发布的视频证据支持了马丁内斯的说法,即被冲撞的是她的车辆,而非特工的。此前对马丁内斯的起诉因诸多问题失败,包括作为证据的特工车辆在事件发生后被驾驶超过1000英里。
用铲子和扫帚袭击特工(1月14日)
声明: 国土安全部在一份声明中称,三名移民(包括一名在明尼阿波利斯腿部中枪的胡利奥·塞萨尔·索萨-塞利斯)“用铲子和扫帚暴力袭击执法人员”。诺姆称这是“对联邦执法人员的谋杀未遂”。
证据: 移民和海关执法局上周承认其特工在宣誓后作了“虚假陈述”,司法部检察官已撤回对其中两人的刑事指控。代理移民和海关执法局局长托德·莱昂斯表示,视频证据反驳了这些指控。
威胁暗杀特朗普(2025年5月)
声明: 国土安全部指控密尔沃基居民拉蒙·莫拉莱斯·雷耶斯写了一封信,信中“威胁暗杀特朗普总统”。诺姆敦促特朗普的批评者收敛言辞。
证据: 上月,另一名男子在法庭上承认,这封信是一个骗局,实际是他所写。该男子据称刺伤了莫拉莱斯·雷耶斯,并希望在其作证前将其驱逐。国土安全部的指控仍在网上,没有迹象表明对莫拉莱斯·雷耶斯的指控是虚假的(反而称他“不再接受调查”)。
格雷格·博维诺与催泪瓦斯(2025年10月23日)
声明: 前明尼阿波利斯行动负责人、边境巡逻队官员格雷格·博维诺声称,他在芝加哥头盔被石块击中后部署了催泪瓦斯。国土安全部也称一块石头“击中了博维诺局长的头部”。
证据: 在一个涉及限制联邦特工使用武力的案件中,法官称博维诺“在证词中承认多次说谎”。法官表示,博维诺的说法多次变化,最终承认在部署催泪瓦斯前没有人向他投掷石块。
对一名青少年的暴力逮捕(2025年10月10日)
声明: 伊利诺伊州霍夫曼庄园一名青少年被暴力逮捕的视频曝光后,麦克劳克林称这是旧视频,且不涉及移民和海关执法局。她称这是“一年前芝加哥警方进行入室盗窃逮捕时拍摄的视频”。
证据: 事实核查网站PolitiFact认定麦克劳克林的说法不实。现场显示特工穿着带有移民和海关执法局标识的制服,且该郊区距离芝加哥30英里,与警方无关。青少年的家人也公开表示质疑。
另一起特工枪击事件,马里兰州(2025年12月24日)
声明: 国土安全部称,两名男子在马里兰州格伦伯尼驾车“直接冲向移民和海关执法局官员”,其中一人被特工开枪击中。
证据: 安妮·阿伦德尔县警方随后表示,其中一名男子当时“已被拘留”。国土安全部随后修改声明,称只有一人在车内。
一名13岁少年与枪支(2025年10月9日)
声明: 麦克劳克林称,一名在马萨诸塞州被移民和海关执法局逮捕拘留的13岁少年“被捕时持有枪支和5-7英寸的刀具”。
证据: 马萨诸塞州埃弗雷特市市长卡洛·德马利亚强烈否认该少年有枪,称“未发现枪支”。(德马利亚证实了刀具的存在)。美国有线电视新闻网要求进一步置评时,国土安全部未回应。
被催泪瓦斯袭击的家庭(1月14日)
声明: 两名儿童在明尼阿波利斯抗议活动附近驾车时被催泪瓦斯袭击,随后入院,国土安全部暗示其父母是“煽动者”。国土安全部在帖子中写道:“看到激进煽动者将孩子带入暴力骚乱,令人震惊。”
证据: 国土安全部很快删除了该帖子,麦克劳克林承认这些人并非煽动者,而是“受害者”。
吕梅萨·奥兹图尔克(2025年3月25日)
声明: 这名塔夫茨大学博士生去年春天被蒙面联邦特工拘留后,麦克劳克林告诉美国有线电视新闻网,调查人员发现奥兹图尔克“从事支持哈马斯(一个外国恐怖组织)的活动”。
证据: 上月,一份新发布的国务院备忘录称,调查人员未发现奥兹图尔克“发表任何表明支持恐怖组织的公开声明”。备忘录称,国土安全部认为没有理由以“向外国恐怖组织提供物质支持或参与恐怖活动”为由将其驱逐。
联邦机构 国家安全 恐怖主义 唐纳德·特朗普
The many claims by Trump’s DHS that have fallen apart
Analysis by Aaron Blake
2 hr ago
PUBLISHED Feb 17, 2026, 4:42 PM ET
Federal agencies National security Terrorism Donald Trump
The imminent exit of Department of Homeland Security spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin from the agency is the latest sign of a reset in the Trump administration’s aggressive deportation strategy, which has fallen sharply out of favor with the American people.
And it’s difficult to overstate how big a role the department’s overly aggressive, poor and often bizarre messaging played in that.
The administration and McLaughlin, who’s set to leave next week, seemed to think they could say whatever they wanted about episodes such as the shootings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti by federal immigration agents, regardless of the evidence. But there proved to be political consequences to that approach.
A Quinnipiac University poll earlier this month showed registered voters said by more than a 2-to-1 margin (61%-25%) that they did not think the administration had given an “honest account” of Pretti’s shooting in Minneapolis in late January.
Even among Republicans, 4 in 10 declined to vouch for the administration. (About half were neutral, while half distrusted it.)
And that reputation was more than earned — if not just via the administration’s botched handling of Pretti’s shooting, but by its handling of many other high-profile incidents.
Over and over again in recent months, DHS has made claims that were later undermined by video, other evidence, local police and/or judges. Its legal cases against people it accused of targeting federal agents repeatedly fell apart.
And while Pretti’s killing was perhaps the most shocking example of the department’s botched messaging, it was of-a-piece with plenty of other examples – including some we learned more about in recent days, shortly before McLaughlin’s exit was reported. (CNN reports that she started to plan her exit in December but stayed on in the aftermath of those Minneapolis shootings.)
Let’s review some examples of big DHS claims that fell apart.
Renee Good (January 7)
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem speaks during a news conference at Federal Emergency Management Agency headquarters, on January 24.
Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP/File
The claims: McLaughlin said Good had “weaponized her vehicle in an attempt to kill or cause bodily harm to federal law enforcement.” Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem called it “an act of domestic terrorism.” And President Donald Trump said Good “willfully and viciously ran over” the agent.
The evidence:Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent Jonathan Ross was not run over. There is some question about whether the vehicle made contact with him. But there remains no evidence that Good aimed to run over the agent; indeed, Good was turning away from the agent as she drove away and was shot. And video evidence shows Ross continuing to shoot her even from the side of the vehicle.
Alex Pretti (January 24)
A picture of Renee Good is covered with flowers at a memorial in Minneapolis on January 29.
Scott Olson/Getty Images
The claims:McLaughlin said it looked like Pretti had aimed to “massacre law enforcement.” Noem again invoked “domestic terrorism.” White House adviser Stephen Miller called Pretti an “assassin” who “tried to murder federal agents.”
The evidence: The video contradicted these claims even more strongly than with Good. There is no evidence that Pretti targeted the agents. He was legally armed but did not draw his gun, and he was disarmed before he was shot and killed. The administration has since backed off of these claims.
Marimar Martinez (October 4, 2025)
A picture of Alex Pretti on January 25 at a memorial in the area where he was killed in Minneapolis.
Octavio Jones/AFP/Getty Images
The claims: Good and Pretti were not the first US citizens to be accused of terrorism. After a Border Patrol agent shot Marimar Martinez several times in Chicago, a DHS statement said the agents involved were “ambushed by domestic terrorists that rammed federal agents with their vehicles.” It said the shots were “defensive.” McLaughlin added: “We will not allow domestic terrorists to attack our law enforcement.”
The evidence:Video evidence released last week bolsters Martinez’s claim that it was her vehicle that was rammed, not the agent’s. And the prosecution of Martinez previously fell apart amid numerous problems, including the fact that the agent’s vehicle — which was due to be evidence — was driven more than 1,000 miles away after the incident.
Attacking agents with shovels and brooms (January 14)
The claims:DHS claimed in a statement that three migrants, including one who was shot in the leg in Minneapolis, Julio Cesar Sosa-Celis, “violently assaulted law enforcement with a shovel and broom.” Noem described an “attempted murder of federal law enforcement.”
The evidence: ICE admitted last week that its agents made “false statements” under oath, and Justice Department prosecutors moved to drop criminal charges against two of the men. Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons said the claims were contradicted by video evidence.
Threats to assassinate Trump (May 2025)
The claims: DHS accused Milwaukee resident Ramón Morales Reyes of writing a letter in which he “threatened to assassinate President Trump.” Noem urged Trump’s critics to tone down their rhetoric.
The evidence: Last month, another man admitted in court that the letter was a ruse, and was actually written by him. The man had allegedly stabbed Morales Reyes and wanted to get him deported before he could testify. DHS’ claim remains online, with no indication that it falsely accused Morales Reyes. (It instead says he was “no longer under investigation.”)
Greg Bovino and tear gas (October 23, 2025)
Marimar Martinez sits for a photograph in Chicago on November 21, 2025.
Leonel Mendez/CNN
The claims: Greg Bovino, the Border Patrol official who formerly led the Minneapolis operation, claimed he deployed tear gas after being struck in the helmet by a rock in Chicago. DHS also said a rock “struck Chief Greg Bovino in the head.”
The evidence: In a case involving limits on federal agents’ use of force, a judge said Bovino “admitted in his deposition that he lied multiple times” about the incident. The judge said Bovino’s claims shifted repeatedly, and he finally admitted no rock had been thrown at him before he deployed the tear gas.
The aggressive apprehension of a teenager (October 10, 2025)
The claims:After video emerged of an aggressive apprehension of a teenager in Hoffman Estates, Illinois, McLaughlin claimed it was old video and didn’t involve ICE. She called it “a video from a burglary arrest Chicago Police made over a year ago.”
The evidence:PolitiFact determined McLaughlin’s claims were false. The scene involved agents wearing uniforms that identified them as tied to ICE, and it would make no sense for the arrest to involve Chicago police, given it was in a suburb 30 miles away. The teenager’s family also spoke out.
Another shooting by an agent, in Maryland (December 24, 2025)
The claims: DHS claimed that two men were in a van that one of them drove “directly at ICE officers,” in Glen Burnie, Maryland. One of them was shot by an agent.
The evidence:Anne Arundel County police later said one of the two men was “already in custody” at the time. DHS later amended its claims to reflect that only one person was in the van.
A 13-year-old and a gun (October 9, 2025)
Greg Bovino leaves a courthouse in Chicago, on October 28, 2025.
Leah Millis/Reuters
The claims: McLaughlin said that a 13-year-old who was arrested and detained by ICE in Massachusetts “was in possession of a firearm and 5-7 inch knife when arrested.”
The evidence: Everett, Massachusetts, Mayor Carlo DeMaria strongly denied the teen had a gun, saying, “No guns were found.” (DeMaria confirmed the knife.) Asked by CNN for further comment, DHS did not respond.
The tear-gassed family (January 14)
Arthur Berto, a 13-year-old living in Everett, Massachusetts, was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Courtesy Josiele Berto
The claims: After two children were hospitalized after being tear-gassed as their family drove near a protest in Minneapolis, DHS suggested their parents were “agitators.” DHS wrote in a post: “It is horrific to see radical agitators bring children to their violent riots.”
The evidence: DHS soon deleted the post, with McLaughlin acknowledging the people were not agitators but instead “victims.”
Rümeysa Öztürk (March 25, 2025)
A family trying to get home from their son’s basketball game found themselves trapped in a protest and tear gassed in their car, resulting in the mother having to administer CPR to her infant.
Yaakov Strasberg/@YaakovStras
The claims: After the Tufts University PhD student was detained by masked federal agents last spring, McLaughlin told CNN that Rümeysa Öztürk had been found by investigators to be “engaged in activities in support of Hamas, a foreign terrorist organization.”
The evidence: Last month, a newly released State Department memo said the investigators did not find that Öztürk had “made any public statements indicating support for a terrorist organization.” It said DHS found no grounds to remove her for “material support to foreign terrorist organization or terrorist activity.”
Federal agencies National security Terrorism Donald Trump