泰坦尼克号文物(含个人物品)计划拍卖遭美国政府反对


2026年6月23日 美国东部时间07:25 / 哥伦比亚广播公司/美联社

根据最新公开的法庭文件,一项拍卖超过100件从泰坦尼克号残骸中打捞上来的文物的计划正遭到美国政府反对,这些文物包括个人物品、货币、厨房用品和装饰摆件。

拥有北大西洋著名沉船专属打捞权的 RMS 泰坦尼克公司,此前曾达成协议仅将文物用于博物馆展览和巡回展出,如今却首次提出拍卖计划。

总部位于佐治亚州的 RMS 泰坦尼克公司提议拍卖这批文物,并在全球四座城市进行巡回展示,不过具体地点尚未公开。美国提交的法庭文件显示,该公司计划拍卖的文物包括一座青铜天使像、一串金珠项链和一枚心形吊坠。

美国国家海洋和大气管理局(NOAA)负责泰坦尼克号沉船遗址的美国利益代表与监管工作。根据本月早些时候法官下令公开的文件,该机构认为此次拍卖将违反 RMS 泰坦尼克公司对该遗址承担的法律义务。

在要求禁止拍卖的论证中,美国政府写道,该公司“未寻求法院批准,认为无需获得批准,并声称其出售文物的能力不受限制”。

RMS 泰坦尼克公司的代表周一未回应置评请求。该公司律师此前在联邦法庭文件中称,拟议的拍卖安排不会违反现有关于这批文物的法院命令和协议。

最新的泰坦尼克文物出售尝试

自1987年以来,打捞作业已取回数千件物品,甚至包括泰坦尼克号船体的碎片。RMS 泰坦尼克公司通过展出这些文物获利。

数十年来,该公司曾多次尝试出售文物以资助未来的勘探工作,并缓解财务困境。但这些努力均遭到美国法院、文物保护组织以及遇难者家属的强烈反对。部分打捞上来的物品属于船上乘客。

不过,幸存者留存或救援人员从水中打捞的物品可以出售,且通常能拍出高价。

今年4月,一名乘客逃生时穿着的泰坦尼克号救生衣在拍卖会上以90.6万美元的价格成交。同一场由亨利·奥尔德里奇父子拍卖行举办的拍卖中,一艘泰坦尼克号救生艇的座垫以52.7万美元的价格售出。

2025年,一名收藏家以超过200万美元的创纪录价格买下一块与泰坦尼克号相关的金怀表。这块18K金怀表是艾达·斯特劳斯送给丈夫伊西多尔·斯特劳斯的43岁生日礼物。伊西多尔·斯特劳斯是美国商人、梅西百货公司所有者,他与妻子均为泰坦尼克号头等舱乘客。

![伊西多尔·斯特劳斯的金怀表。亨利·奥尔德里奇父子拍卖行供图]

近年来售出的其他文物还包括一份首航餐单、一张登船票,以及美国乘客奥斯卡·霍尔弗森写下的浸水信件。2013年,一把据传在泰坦尼克号沉没前曾被演奏的小提琴在拍卖会上以145万美元的价格成交。

拍卖行表示,公众对泰坦尼克号的持久兴趣——这艘1912年在从欧洲前往纽约的首航途中撞上冰山沉没,造成超过1500人遇难的邮轮——以及文物的稀缺性,推高了市场需求和拍品价格。

跨大西洋文物争端

RMS 泰坦尼克公司计划拍卖首批从沉船中打捞的部分文物。这些物品被运往法国,法国法院将其所有权判给了打捞方。法国海洋研究所 IFREMER 曾与伍兹霍尔海洋研究所合作发现该沉船遗址。

其余藏品是在后续探险中打捞上来的,打捞权主张已提交至美国弗吉尼亚州诺福克的联邦地区法院。

NOAA 认为,大约5000件文物——无论其打捞权是在法国还是美国主张的——都必须按照美国法院设定的条件保持完整的单一馆藏。NOAA 还在其网站上称,法国法院的条件要求文物不得单独出售,必须作为一个整体馆藏保存。

该公司辩称,除其他事项外,美国法院对在法国主张所有权的物品没有管辖权。

法国政府代表周一晚些时候未回应置评请求。

历史碎片的归属争议

一些海底勘探者反对出售泰坦尼克号文物,他们认为这些文物应出于公共利益进行展览。

“只要打捞工作谨慎开展,采用恰当的考古技术,我并不反对人们从泰坦尼克号上打捞文物,”资深海洋探险家、海洋科学家格雷格·斯通说道,“如果这是一项非营利项目,我会更安心。”

波士顿东北大学法学院专门从事公共利益维权的法学教授理查德·戴纳德表示,关于泰坦尼克号文物展览和出售的规定,旨在为公众利益保护沉船遗址,因此不能让“亿万富翁收购这些文物以炫耀其财富和权力”。

“如果有人可以在家里摆着这件藏品说‘没错,我花500万美元买下了这件泰坦尼克号原物’,那绝非好事,”他说道。

https://www.cbsnews.com/video/gold-pocket-watch-becomes-most-expensive-piece-of-memorabilia-linked-to-titanic/

Planned auction of Titanic artifacts including personal belongings faces U.S. government pushback

2026-06-23 07:25 EDT / CBS/AP

A plan to auction more than 100 artifacts salvaged from the wreckage of the Titanic – including personal belongings, currency, kitchen items and decor – is facing pushback from the U.S. government, according to newly unsealed court documents.

RMS Titanic Inc., the company that owns exclusive salvage rights to the famous wreck in the North Atlantic, wants to sell the artifacts for the first time despite previous agreements to only display them at museums and traveling exhibitions.

Georgia-based RMS Titanic proposed auctioning the artifacts and displaying them on a global tour in four cities, although those locations haven’t been publicly revealed. Court documents filed in the U.S. referenced the company’s plan to sell artifacts including a bronze cherub, a necklace of gold nuggets and a heart-shaped pendant.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration represents U.S. interests and oversight in the wreck site. The agency contends such a sale would violate RMS Titanic’s legal obligations to the site, according to documents a judge ordered unsealed earlier this month.

In arguing that the auction should be prohibited, the government wrote that the company “does not seek the Court’s approval, does not believe that approval is required, and asserts that it is not restricted in its ability to sell” the artifacts.

Representatives for RMS Titanic did not respond to requests for comment Monday. Its attorneys previously said in a federal court filing that the proposed auction arrangement wouldn’t violate existing court orders and agreements about the artifacts.

Latest attempt to sell Titanic artifacts

Since 1987, salvage operations have retrieved thousands of items and even chunks of the Titanic’s hull. RMS Titanic makes money by exhibiting them.

Over the decades, the company has tried to sell artifacts to fund future explorations and as it faced financial trouble. But those efforts were roundly opposed by U.S. courts along with preservation groups and relatives of the victims. Some of the salvaged items belonged to passengers aboard the ship.

However, items saved by survivors or plucked from the water by rescuers can be sold and often fetch big sums.

In April, a life jacket worn by a passenger on the Titanic as she escaped the sinking steamship on a lifeboat sold at auction for $906,000. A seat cushion from one of the Titanic lifeboats sold at the same Henry Aldridge & Son auction for $527,000.

In 2025, a collector paid a record price of over $2 million for a gold pocket watch linked to the Titanic. The 18-carat gold watch was gifted to its original owner, Isidor Straus, by his wife, Ida Straus, for his 43rd birthday. Straus, an American businessman and owner of Macy’s, and his wife were first-class passengers on the Titanic.

Isidor Straus’ gold pocket watch. Henry Aldridge and Son

Other items sold in recent years include a menu from a first meal, a launch ticket and a water-logged letter written by American passenger Oscar Holverson. In 2013, a violin believed to have been played on the Titanic before the doomed vessel sank sold for $1.45 million at auction.

Auctioneers say the unending fascination with the Titanic – which sank in 1912 after hitting an iceberg on its maiden voyage from Europe to New York, killing more than 1,500 people – and the rarity of artifacts adds up to high demand and exorbitant prices.

Trans-Atlantic dispute over the artifacts

RMS Titanic wants to auction some of the first artifacts salvaged from the wreck. Those items were taken to France, which awarded ownership of them to the salvager. French oceanographic institute IFREMER partnered with Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution on the discovery of the wreck.

The rest of the collection was retrieved during subsequent expeditions, and the salvage claim was made in a U.S. District Court in Norfolk, Virginia.

NOAA argues that all of the roughly 5,000 items – regardless of whether they were claimed in France or the U.S. – must remain in one collection based on conditions set by the U.S. court. NOAA also maintains on its website that a French court’s conditions required that the artifacts not be sold individually and be kept together as a single collection.

The company has argued, among other things, that the U.S. court lacks jurisdiction over the items claimed in France.

Representatives for the French government did not respond to requests for comment late Monday.

Pieces of history

Some undersea explorers have pushed back at the idea of selling Titanic artifacts, which they argue should be displayed in the public interest.

“I don’t have a problem with people recovering artifacts from the Titanic as long as it’s done careful, with proper archaeological techniques,” said Greg Stone, a veteran ocean explorer and ocean scientist. “I’d feel better if it was a nonprofit enterprise.”

Richard Daynard, a law professor at Northeastern University School of Law in Boston who specializes in public interest advocacy, said rules on the display and sale of Titanic artifacts are intended to preserve the wreckage for the benefit of the public, and so it can’t be “picked up by billionaires for further display of their wealth and power.”

“If it’s something where someone can walk through their house and say ‘Yes, I bought this for $5 million and it’s original from the Titanic,’ that’s not a good thing,” he said.

https://www.cbsnews.com/video/gold-pocket-watch-becomes-most-expensive-piece-of-memorabilia-linked-to-titanic/

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注