伊朗48小时后：战术成功，战略不确定性

Iran after 48 hours: Tactical success, strategic uncertainty

Analysis by Brett H. McGurk, Updated Mar 2, 2026, 1:28 AM ET, PUBLISHED Mar 2, 2026, 12:00 AM ET

People watch from a rooftop as a plume of smoke rises after a strike in Tehran, Iran, on Sunday.

Vahid Salemi/AP

Brett McGurk is a CNN global affairs analyst who served in senior national security positions under Presidents George W. Bush, Barack Obama, Donald Trump and Joe Biden.

During a crisis like what is now unfolding in the Middle East, a president receives a net assessment prepared from intelligence and military sources. It might evaluate the balance of forces, leadership dynamics and strategic calculations — without making policy recommendations. Its purpose is clarity: a baseline from which decisions can be made.

We do not have access to the stream of reporting flowing into the Situation Room. But enough is visible to construct a disciplined baseline assessment.

Here are the ten issues that matter most — and what to watch next.

1. Air dominance over Iran

In the early hours Saturday night, US military forces reportedly destroyed whatever was left of Iran’s air defenses. There was not much there as much of Iran’s Russian supplied systems were destroyed in previous strikes by Israel over the last year.

The American and Israel sides now appear to have air dominance over Iran. That means U.S. and Israeli aircraft can fly at will with manageable risk for as long as this conflict continues—and afterwards.

1. Iranian leadership disarray

Trump has reported that 48 top Iranian leaders were killed in the initial hours of the air campaign, including Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei. This would be the equivalent of the American president, chairman of the Joint Chiefs, and multiple Cabinet officials killed in a moment

For a country like Iran that has only had one leader succession since its 1979 civil war, this is likely to cause deep disarray and uncertainty throughout Iran’s chain of command. On Sunday, Iran’s foreign minister acknowledged in an interview that its military units are likely acting independently and out of contact with a chain of command above them.

That’s an acknowledgment that even Iranian officials may be unsure who’s in charge.

1. Succession uncertainty

Iran’s regime has sought to reassure its followers that a succession to replace Khamenei is underway, with a process outlined in its constitution. This means an interim council led by its president, chief justice, and a cleric to be named is purportedly making decisions, But none have been seen publicly, and Israeli and US aircraft are continuing to target Iran’s leadership. A strike was reported Saturday in the vicinity of where former Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is said to live.

Also, there is no clear successor to Khamenei. One top candidate, another former president, Ebrahim Raisi, died in a helicopter crash two years ago. Another, Khamenei’s son, Mojtaba, would face several hurdles despite his strong links with the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Absent a named successor, the foundation of Iran’s Islamic republic may further erode over the coming weeks

People gather to mourn Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in Tehran on Sunday.

Majid Asgaripour/WANA/Reuters

A woman holds a picture Khamenei in Tehran on Sunday.

Majid Asgaripour/WANA/Reuters

4. Missile math

Iran is responding to the American and Israeli blows with missile attacks into Israel, American facilities in the region, and civilian targets across the Gulf. The top priority for US and Israeli military commanders in these early days is to degrade Iran’s missile capabilities — particularly its launchers. The launchers determine how many missiles Iran can fire per salvo. This will be difficult. Iran has limited quantities of longer-range missiles to reach Israel, but it has larger stockpiles of short- and medium-range missiles for closer range targets, such as in Iraq or the Gulf states. They are also likely dispersed and hidden before use.

Over the coming days, I’ll be watching to see whether Iran can sustain the barrages we’ve seen in early hours, or whether military strikes into Iran are having the desired degradation effect.

1. Gulf states: Off the sidelines

The most surprising development for me in these early hours has been Iran’s decision to target civilian infrastructure, hotels, and residences in the Gulf states — Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar, Bahrain, Kuwait, and Oman. US Central Command on Sunday put out a list of what’s been targeted, after Iran claimed to be focused solely on American military bases

[Related article Clipped From Video From Tehran to Dubai: Geolocated videos show the shockwaves of US-Israeli strikes — and Iran’s retaliation 4 min read]

These countries wanted to remain out of this conflict, but Iran’s attacks are now drawing them in. Political disagreements have been put aside in the face of a common threat. Now, there is consideration of how to respond. Should some of the Gulf states join strikes into Iran, that would be a significant development, reversing years of work by Iran to reconcile with its Arab neighbors.

Note: The UK, France, and Germany on Sunday issued a joint statement saying they might also join in strikes against Iran’s missile and drone supplies. This indicates a possible coalition emerging against Iran.

By late Sunday, a broader coalition appeared to be forming. Following the E3, five Gulf states and Jordan joined the US in condemning Iran and asserting their “right to self defense” against Iran’s attacks.

6. Russia and China — absent for now

Iran historically has touted its strategic partnership with Russia and China. Its provided missiles and drones for Russia to use in Ukraine, and had relied on Russian air defense systems. Those are now destroyed and Russia has no capacity to replace them. As for China, it depends on cheap Iranian oil (80% of Iran’s oil goes to China) as well as global trade through the Strait of Hormuz.

Moscow and Beijing have said little even after the death of their partner, Khamenei. Late Sunday, a reported phone call between the foreign ministers of Russia and China offered verbal condemnation of the American and Israeli strikes, but not much else. That’s unlikely to change. Iran is standing on its own.

7. No major asymmetric response — yet

Iran’s asymmetric toolkit — cyber operations, proxy militias, maritime disruption — appears dormant thus far. Iranian officials backed off threats to close the Strait of Hormuz, and US forces are reportedly targeting Iran’s navy. Iran’s crown jewel proxy, Hezbollah, is already battered and thus far not engaged on Iran’s northern border. Militias in Iraq have fired drones at the airport in Erbil, but Iraqi leaders are working to keep its country out of the crosshairs. Nonetheless, this is an area to watch, as lack of action may reflect disarray — or preparation.

8. Energy shock

Any sustained conflict involving Iran raises oil prices — especially if maritime traffic through the Strait of Hormuz is threatened. That is certain whether Iran acts to shut down the strait or not. On Sunday, OPEC, the oil producing countries led by Saudi Arabia, agreed to increase production by more than 200 thousand barrels per day. Still, oil prices rose 10% as markets opened on Sunday evening.

Traders will be watching markets closely over the coming days. Iran will hope that a price boost raises domestic pressure on Trump, who’s aimed to keep prices low.

Video Ad Feedback

Former Pentagon spokesperson predicts price jump at gas pump

8:22 • Source: CNN

Former Pentagon spokesperson predicts price jump at gas pump

8:22

However, global markets have changed since the days of Middle East energy crises decades ago. The United States is now the largest producer in the world, and any significant global price disruption from Middle East exports is likely to be short lived.

9. Escalation dominance— not outcome dominance

Militarily, the United States maintains overwhelming conventional superiority: airpower, naval strike groups, global intelligence reach and logistics depth. If Iran chooses to significantly escalate, the US together with Israel retain multiple options and targets across Iran. That advantage over time might shape Iranian calculations and support more pragmatic voices in the leadership transition.

Military advantage alone, however, cannot deliver political outcomes and it’s probable at this stage that Iran’s new leaders remain committed to its ideology of revolution and hostility towards the West.

In pictures: Middle East tensions escalate after …

44 photos

In pictures: Middle East tensions escalate after US-Israel strikes on Iran

-1 / 44

The remains of a car are seen in Tehran on Saturday.

Amir Kholousi/ISNA/Wana News Agency/Reuters

0 / 44

Smoke rises from a burning building hit by an Iranian drone strike in Manama, Bahrain, on Saturday.

Hamad I. Mohammed/Reuters

1 / 44

A fire is seen in a damaged building after an Israeli airstrike in Beirut’s southern suburb neighborhood of Haret Hreik, in Lebanon, on March 2, 2026.

AFP/Getty Images

2 / 44

Children sit on a sidewalk as displaced families fleeing Israeli strikes in southern Lebanon arrive in the southern port city of Sidon, early on Monday.

Mohammad Zaatari/AP

3 / 44

People gather at the site of a deadly missile strike in Beit Shemesh, Israel, on Sunday, March 1.

Leo Correa/AP

4 / 44

In this photo released by the US Navy, the USS Thomas Hudner fires a Tomahawk missile from an undisclosed location on Sunday.

US Navy/Reuters

5 / 44

Emergency personnel carry a body at the site of a strike in Beit Shemesh on Sunday.

Ammar Awad/Reuters

6 / 44

Smoke rises above the city after Tehran, Iran, was targeted by US and Israel led airstrikes on Sunday.

Fatemeh Bahrami/Anadolu/Getty Images

7 / 44

People react as they gather at Enghelab Square in Tehran on Sunday while holding a picture of Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who was killed a day earlier in Israeli and US strikes.

Majid Asgaripour/West Asia News Agency/Reuters

8 / 44

Rescue workers and military personnel survey the site of a missile strike in Tel Aviv, Israel, on Sunday.

Oded Balilty/AP

9 / 44

Stranded passengers wait near Emirates Airways customer service office at I Gusti Ngurah Rai International Airport in Bali, Indonesia, after flights to the Middle East were cancelled on Sunday.

Johannes P. Christo/Reuters

10 / 44

Government supporters in Tehran gather on Sunday in mourning after state TV officially announced the death of Khamenei.

Vahid Salemi/AP

11 / 44

An officer from Israel’s Home Front Command searches through the rubble of a destroyed house after it was struck by a missile in Beit Shemesh on Sunday.

Leo Correa/AP

12 / 44

Leah Guttmann holds her son, Teddy, while taking shelter in an underground parking garage as air-raid sirens warn of incoming missiles in Tel Aviv on Sunday.

Ohad Zwigenberg/AP

13 / 44

Residents watch from the roofs of their houses as plumes of smoke rise following reported explosions in Tehran on Sunday.

Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images

14 / 44

People prepare to spend the night sleeping in an underground shelter in Tel Aviv on Saturday, February 28.

Alexi J. Rosenfeld/Getty Images

15 / 44

A fire burns after a retaliatory strike in Tel Aviv on Saturday.

Erik Marmor/Getty Images

16 / 44

Protesters shout slogans as they carry portraits of Khamenei and wave Iranian flags near the US embassy in Baghdad on Saturday.

Ahmad Al-Rubaye/AFP/Getty Images

17 / 44

Emergency responders and residents gather at the site of a reported Iranian missile strike in central Israel late Saturday.

Amit Elkayam/The New York Times/Redux

18 / 44

An intercepted missile is seen from Doha, Qatar, on Saturday.

Saleh Salem/Reuters

19 / 44

Emergency workers inspect damage to the Fairmont The Palm hotel in Dubai on Saturday.

Altaf Qadri/AP

20 / 44

Emergency workers assist civilians after a strike in Tel Aviv on Saturday.

Erik Marmor/Getty Images

21 / 44

An explosion lights up the night sky as a missile hits a building in Tel Aviv on Saturday.

Tomer Neuberg/AP

22 / 44

Iranain Americas Sadaf Ebrahimi and Shirin Nariman, supporters of the National Council of Resistance of Iran, react to reports that Khamenei was killed Saturday while watching the news at Nariman’s home in Vienna, Virginia.

Nathan Howard/Reuters

23 / 44

Heavy traffic clogs the streets of Tehran on Saturday.

Majid Asgaripour/Wana News Agency/Reuters

24 / 44

An air defense system operates in Jerusalem as missiles are launched toward Israel from Iran on Saturday.

Ronen Zvulun/Reuters

25 / 44

Children climb on the wreckage of a missile that was reportedly intercepted by Israeli forces on Saturday in the southern countryside of Quneitra, Syria, near the Golan Heights.

Bakr Alkasem/AFP/Getty Images

26 / 44

In this photo [released by The White House], President Donald Trump, chief of staff Susie Wiles and Secretary of State Marco Rubio monitor US military operations in Iran on Saturday from the president’s Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida. Portions of the photo have been blurred by the source.

The White House

27 / 44

This image from video provided by US Central Command shows a missile being launched from a US Navy ship on Saturday.

US Central Command/AP

28 / 44

Staff members transfer patients to an underground shelter at the Ichilov hospital in Tel Aviv following an air raid warning on Saturday.

Amit Elkayam/The New York Times/Redux

29 / 44

People wave Iranian flags during a rally in Tehran on Saturday.

Arash Khamooshi/The New York Times/Redux

30 / 44

A woman looks out from her rooftop garden in Tehran after large explosions shook the city on Saturday.

Arash Khamooshi/The New York Times/Redux

31 / 44

An explosion in the sea is seen from Haifa, Israel, on Saturday.

Rami Shlush/Reuters

32 / 44

People sort through rubble in Tehran on Saturday.

Amir Kholousi/ISNA/Wana News Agency/Reuters

33 / 44

People take shelter in Ashkelon, Israel, after missiles were launched from Iran on Saturday.

Amir Cohen/Reuters

34 / 44

People watch as smoke rises over the Tehran skyline after an explosion on Saturday, February 28.

AP

35 / 44

Smoke billows above the compound of Iran’s supreme leader in Tehran on Saturday.

Airbus

36 / 44

People play racketball outside an underground parking garage used as a shelter in Tel Aviv on Saturday.

John Wessels/AFP/Getty Images

37 / 44

Rescue workers and residents search through the rubble of a girls’ elementary school in Minab, Iran, on Saturday.

Abbas Zakeri/Mehr News Agency/AP

38 / 44

A missile is intercepetd over the Israeli coastal city of Netanya on Saturday.

Jack Guez/AFP/Getty Images

39 / 44

People in in Doha watch from their balcony following explosions after Qatar’s defense ministry said it had downed missiles targeting the country on Saturday.

Mohammed Salem/Reuters

40 / 44

A person takes shelter as sirens sound in Jerusalem on Saturday.

Ahmad Gharabli/AFP/Getty Images

41 / 44

People take shelter under a highway bridge near Latrun, Israel, on Saturday.

Amir Cohen/Reuters

42 / 44

Birds fly overhead after an airstrike in Tehran on Saturday.

Majid Asgaripour/WANA/Reuters

43 / 44

The remains of a car are seen in Tehran on Saturday.

Amir Kholousi/ISNA/Wana News Agency/Reuters

44 / 44

Smoke rises from a burning building hit by an Iranian drone strike in Manama, Bahrain, on Saturday.

Hamad I. Mohammed/Reuters

45 / 44

A fire is seen in a damaged building after an Israeli airstrike in Beirut’s southern suburb neighborhood of Haret Hreik, in Lebanon, on March 2, 2026.

AFP/Getty Images

46 / 44

Children sit on a sidewalk as displaced families fleeing Israeli strikes in southern Lebanon arrive in the southern port city of Sidon, early on Monday.

Mohammad Zaatari/AP

Prev Next

In pictures: Middle East tensions escalate after US-Israel strikes on Iran

10. No natural endpoint

Wars, once begun, carry their own momentum with variables often not considered at the outset. It is impossible to predict 48 hours in where this is all leading. The main concern at this stage from Washington’s vantage point — even after the extraordinary military success — is that there’s no clear offramp or natural endpoint to the campaign. Even in the best case of an Iranian uprising against what’s left of the regime, those remnants will likely act to suppress protests once again with lethal force. It’s an open question whether the United States would then use air power to deter another crackdown. Those are the questions that must be considered — now.

Bottom line

Strategic and tactical advantage can coexist with profound uncertainty about where this all leads. That is likely the net assessment Trump is receiving.

The Middle East Russia National security

[See all topics]